Sonic the Hedgehog movie: Critics put the brakes on

Sonic the HedgehogImage copyright
Paramount Pictures

Image caption

Sonic the Hedgehog is on the run from the US government

The reviews are in for the new-and-improved Sonic the Hedgehog movie, and the critics have been getting their (human) teeth stuck in.

The trailer was out last May, but Sonic went back to the drawing board after fans reacted badly to how he looked.

Variety said he “has been redesigned to satisfy fans, but no-one figured out how to make him as fun as he is fast”.

And IndieWire declared that “fixing Sonic’s terrifying face hasn’t made this movie any less of a nightmare”.

Image copyright
Paramount Pictures

Image caption

Jim Carrey’s Dr Robotnik is described as “more fun and far more animated” than Sonic

Jim Carrey plays Dr Robotnik, who – as well as the US government – is chasing the supersonic Sega hedgehog, portrayed in voice and facial motion capture by Ben Schwartz.

The Guardian gave the film two stars, noting how “dastardly Jim Carrey gives Sonic the blues”.

The paper’s critic Steve Rose wrote: “Carrey’s moustache-twirling villain is more fun and far more animated than the charmless hero in this derivative caper.”

Skip Youtube post by Paramount Pictures UK

End of Youtube post by Paramount Pictures UK

Image Copyright Paramount Pictures UK
Paramount Pictures UK

The Telegraph was similarly unenthused. “The video game speed freak [is] slowed down to a drab, joyless crawl,” wrote Robbie Collin.

Before he was a movie star, Sonic first appeared as a thrill-seeking Sega video game character in the mid-90s.

The New York Times concluded that the “Sega adaptation hedges its bets”. Ben Kenigsberg wrote: “Improvements to Sonic’s appearance haven’t done much for a generic script.”

Image copyright
Paramount Pictures

Image caption

Sonic’s teeth before (right) and after

The film finds sheriff Tom Wachowski – portrayed by James Mardsen – befriend Sonic and aid him in his quest to stop Robotnik’s world domination.

Some found heart-warming elements to enjoy. “Sonic the Hedgehog is really a buddy comedy about Tom and Sonic,” wrote Gamespot’s Phil Hornshaw. “And it’s at its best when it leans into that dynamic.”

He added: “Schwartz is a perfect choice for this version of Sonic, who’s a little irreverent and intensely tuned in to American pop culture somehow, but also earnest and upbeat.”

  • Sonic’s teeth and why video game movies struggle
  • Sonic The Hedgehog gets ‘glow up of the century’

“He’s too cute not to love,” pleaded Dami Lee in The Verge – but with a caveat.

“The new Sonic is so adorable that it almost makes up for a pretty generic plot and a human cast that play the roles of ‘heroic’ and ‘bad’ so straight, they could be extras in The Good Place.”

Sonic the Hedgehog is out on Friday.

Follow us on Facebook or on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts. If you have a story suggestion email